What is control theory in AI?
by Stephen M. Walker II, CoFounder / CEO
What is control theory in AI?
Control theory in AI is the study of how agents can best interact with their environment to achieve a desired goal. The objective is to design algorithms that enable these agents to make optimal decisions, while taking into account the uncertainty of the environment.
Control theory is often used in the development of autonomous systems, robotics, and optimization algorithms. It involves the use of mathematical models, such as Markov decision processes (MDPs), to represent decisionmaking problems where an agent must choose between different actions.
One of the key differences between control theory and AI lies in the mathematical techniques used. Control theory typically involves modeling systems with differential equations, which are wellsuited to systems describable by fixed sets of continuous variables. On the other hand, AI uses tools of logical inference and computation, allowing it to tackle problems such as vision and planning that fall outside the control theorist’s purview.
Control theory can be mathematically complex and may make assumptions about the system that may not be realistic. However, it provides safety guarantees that are crucial for systems where failure can be catastrophic, such as in aircraft or chemical plants.
In the context of AI, control theory can be used to optimize AI systems, making them more efficient and effective. It can also help us understand the behavior of AI systems, enabling us to design them better to achieve our goals.
For instance, control theory can be applied to develop rapid predictive models for engineered multiphase flow, optimize hypertension management strategies, and develop methods for assistive robots to learn correct actions from human experts.
How does control theory differ from other fields of AI?
Control theory and other fields of AI, while interconnected, have distinct differences in their approaches, methodologies, and applications.
Control theory is primarily concerned with modeling systems using differential equations and designing systems that maximize an objective function over time. It is often used in the control layer of systems, where classical control algorithms such as Linear Quadratic Regulator (LQR) and ProportionalIntegralDerivative (PID) are applied. Control theory is particularly suited to systems that can be described by fixed sets of continuous variables.
On the other hand, other fields of AI, such as machine learning (ML) and reinforcement learning (RL), use more advanced techniques like neural networks and expert systems. These fields are typically used at the guidance layer of systems and are more focused on programmed intelligence. They are capable of handling a broader range of problems, including those that involve noncontinuous or discrete variables, and those that require learning from data.
While control theory provides a robust mathematical framework for system control, it can be mathematically complex and often makes assumptions about the system that may not be realistic or accurate. In contrast, ML and RL techniques can adapt and learn from data, making them more flexible and capable of handling complex, nonlinear systems. However, the solutions produced by ML or RL are often harder to verify, which can be a concern for critical systems.
In the context of robotics, control theory could be seen as the underlying mechanism that ensures the robot behaves in a certain way, while AI (including ML and RL) is often considered an input to the control system, providing the intelligence that guides the robot's actions.
While control theory and other fields of AI share the common goal of designing systems that behave optimally, they differ in their mathematical techniques, assumptions, complexity, and the types of problems they are best suited to handle.
What are some challenges in applying control theory to AI?
Applying control theory to AI presents several challenges:

Uncertainty and Variability — Realworld environments are often unpredictable and variable. Designing control systems that can effectively cope with these uncertainties is a significant challenge.

Adaptability — Creating control systems that can learn from and adapt to changing conditions is difficult. This is particularly challenging when dealing with nonstationary processes, where the statistical properties change over time.

Safety and Reliability — Ensuring that control systems are safe and reliable is crucial, especially in critical systems where failure can have catastrophic consequences. Traditional control theory often provides guaranteed behavior, which is not always the case with AI and machine learning methods.

Modeling Complexity — Accurate modeling of the system is a key aspect of control theory. However, creating a model that accurately represents the system and its interactions with the environment can be complex. This is further complicated by the need for the model to be robust against errors that may degrade performance.

Mathematical Complexity — Control theory can be mathematically complex, making it difficult to apply to realworld systems. This complexity can pose a barrier to its implementation and understanding.

Limitations of AI and Machine Learning — AI and machine learning's strengths, such as modelfree learning based on massive data sets, can become weaknesses when applied to realtime varying systems. These methods may lack the safety guarantees provided by traditional control theory.